PROPANE vs NATURAL GAS — THE DIFFERENCES THAT KILL EXAM SCORES
Specific gravity, manifold pressure, codebook, leak detection, combustion air. The TSSA G2/G3 exams test you on the differences — not the similarities. Here's the side-by-side every Ontario gas fitter should have memorized.
SIDE-BY-SIDE COMPARISON
Memorize this table. It accounts for ~10-15 questions on the G2/G3 exams.
| PROPERTY | NATURAL GAS | PROPANE (LP) | WHY IT MATTERS |
|---|---|---|---|
| Specific Gravity | ~0.6 (lighter than air) | ~1.5 (heavier than air) | Determines where leaks accumulate — high (NG) vs low (LP) |
| Heating Value | ~1,000 BTU/ft³ | ~2,500 BTU/ft³ | Why propane orifices are smaller for same BTU output |
| Manifold Pressure | 3.5" w.c. | 11" w.c. | Different regulator springs; never interchange |
| Supply Pressure (typical) | 7" w.c. (utility) | 11" w.c. (after 2nd-stage) | Propane uses 2-stage regulation from tank |
| LEL / UEL | 5% / 15% | 2.1% / 9.5% | Propane has narrower flammable range — but ignites at lower concentrations |
| Ignition Temperature | ~1,150°F | ~920-1,020°F | Propane ignites more easily — extra caution near sparks |
| Air Required (combustion) | ~10 ft³ air per ft³ gas | ~24 ft³ air per ft³ gas | Propane needs more combustion air per unit volume |
| Odorization | Mercaptan added by utility | Ethyl mercaptan in tank | Same family, but propane odorant can fade ("odorant fade") in new tanks |
| Primary Code | CSA B149.1 | CSA B149.1 (install) + B149.2 (storage/handling) | Two separate codes for propane — know which clause is in which book |
NATURAL GAS — KEY POINTS
- → Lighter than air — leaks rise. Check ceilings first.
- → Delivered at utility pressure (~7" w.c.), regulated to 3.5" w.c. at appliance.
- → One code: CSA B149.1 covers everything from meter to appliance.
- → Wider flammable range (5-15%) but harder to ignite.
- → Single-stage regulation typical for residential.
PROPANE — KEY POINTS
- → Heavier than air — leaks pool in basements, pits, low spots. Check low FIRST.
- → 2-stage regulation: tank pressure (~100+ psi) → 1st stage (~10 psi) → 2nd stage (11" w.c.).
- → Two codes apply: B149.1 (installation) + B149.2 (storage/handling).
- → Higher heating value = smaller orifices. Never use NG orifices on propane.
- → "Odorant fade" risk in new tanks — always pressure test, never trust nose alone.
EXAM TRAPS
SPECIFIC GRAVITY CONFUSION
NG is 0.6 (lighter), propane is 1.5 (heavier). Mix these up and you fail every leak-detection question.
MANIFOLD PRESSURE SWAP
3.5" w.c. for NG, 11" w.c. for propane. The exam will give you a regulator failure scenario — know which is which.
WRONG CODEBOOK REFERENCE
A question about a propane storage tank? That's B149.2, not B149.1. Wrong book = wrong clause = wrong answer.
COMBUSTION AIR CALCULATION
Propane needs more air per unit volume. If a question gives you a propane appliance in a confined space, the air requirement is bigger than the equivalent NG calc.
CONVERSION SHORTCUTS
You CANNOT field-convert NG to propane (or vice versa) without a manufacturer kit. Any "field convert with a smaller orifice" answer is wrong.
GET THE PROPANE vs NG QUICK-REFERENCE CARD
A printable one-pager with every property, pressure, and code reference — folded to fit in your B149.1 codebook. We'll email it now.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. We never sell emails.